| John J. Brown 1854 | Charles D. Beckwith 1887-1888 | John Hinchliffe 1929-1937 |
| Brant Van Blarcom 1855 | Nathan Barnert 1889-1890 | Bernard L. Stafford 1938-1940 |
| Samuel Smith 1856 | Thomas Beveridge 1891-1892 | William P. Furrey 1941-1947 |
| Peregrine Sandford 1857-1858 | Christian Braun 1893-1896 | Michael U. De Vita 1948-1951 |
| Silas D. Canfield 1859 | John Hinchliffe 1897-1903 | Lester F. Titus 1952-1955 |
| Edwin S. Prall 1860-1861 | William Belcher 1904-1905 | Edward J. O’Byrne 1956-1959 |
| Henry A. Williams 1867 | David Young 1 1905-1906 | William H. Dillistin 1959-1960 |
| William G. Watson 1866 | John Johnson 1906-1907 | Frank X. Graves Jr. 1961-1966 |
| Henry A. Williams 1867 | William Berdan 1907 | Lawrence F. Kramer 1967-1971 |
| Nathaniel Townsend 1868 | Andrew F. McBride 1908-1913 | Arthur Dwyer 1971-1972 |
| John Ryle 1869-1870 | Robert H. Fordyce 1914-1915 | Thomas C. Rooney Jr. 1971-1975 |
| Socrates Tuttle 1871-1872 | Amos H. Radcliffe 1916-1919 | Lawrence F. Kramer 1975-1979 |
| Nathaniel Townsend 1873-1874 | Clifford L. Newman 3 1919 | Frank X. Graves 1980-1990 |
| Benjamin Buckley 1875-1878 | Frank J. Van Noort 1920-1923 | Anna-Lisa Dopirak 7 1990 |
| Joseph R. Graham 1879-1880 | Colin McLean 1924-1927 | William J. Pascrell Jr. 1990- 1997 |
| David S. Gilmore 1881-1882 | Raymond J. Newman 1928 | Martin G. Barnes 8 1997 – 2002 |
| Nathan Barnert 1883-1886 | Wilmer Cadmus 4 1928 | Jose (Joey) Torres 2002 – . |
| Jeffery Jones | Jose (Joey) Torres | Jane Williams -2018 |
| Andre Sayegh 2018- | ||
1. In 1905 David Young, president of the Board of Alderman, served as acting mayor when William H. Belcher resigned from office.
2. In 1907 William Berdan, President of the Board of Finance, became acting mayor, filling the vacancy caused by the death of Mayor Johnson. 3. Clifford L. Newman, president of the Board of Finance, became acting mayor in 1919 when Mayor Amos H. Radcliff resigned to serve in Congress.
4. Mayor Raymond J. Newman died June 13, 1928, five months and two weeks after he took office. William Cadmus, president of the board of Finance, filled the vacancy until the general election in November when Mayor John V. Hinchliffe was elected for the unexpired term.
5. Following the death of Mayor O’Bryne in December, 1959, William H. Dillistin, president of the Board of Finance, served as mayor for the unexpired term ending December 31, 1960.
6. Mayor Lawrence F. Kramer resigned from office to become the commissioner of the New Jersey Department of Community Affairs. Arthur C. Dwyer, president of the Board of Finance, became acting mayor October 15, 1971.
7. Mayor Frank X. Graves Jr. died march 4, 1990. Anna Lisa Dopirack, City Business Administrator, filled the vacancy until a general election was held in May, when Mayor William Pascrall was elected.
8. Martin G. Barnes, 3rd Ward Councilman, became acting mayor in 1997, when Mayor William Pascrell resigned to serve in Congress.